#38: Brighton 1-0 Newcastle 28/01/2012

#38 BRIGHTON 1-0 NEWCASTLE FA Cup Round Four
Saturday 28th January 2012 Related image

NEW Titles

PRESENTER Ray Stubbs GUESTS Steve Harper & John Barnes
COMMENTATORS Jon Champion & Chris Waddle REPORTER Dave Beckett
5.15pm Kick Off; Amex Stadium     4.30-7.45pm FA Cup Live on ESPN

NEW Promo NEW Bumper NEW Intro

Context of the Match: What a great first season Brighton were having at the American Express Community Stadium. They adapted well to life back in the Championship after five seasons away with a flying start, having the opportunity to go top of the table back in September. They’d already knocked out Premier League Sunderland and performed admirably against Liverpool, both in the Carling Cup. Today it was the turn of Newcastle United, managed by Alan Pardew, to go up against Gus Poyet’s hard-to-beat Brighton. The Albion knocked out United in a Third Round Replay away thanks to Peter Ward’s goal during the historic run to the 1983 FA Cup Final and would be hoping for a similar victory here. The Magpies had already provided Brighton with two players so far this season; goalkeeper Steve Harper played five times from October on-loan whilst winger Kazenga LuaLua finally made his move down south a permanent one after several loan spells. Newcastle were going well in the Premier League sat in sixth place and reached the Fourth Round of the Carling Cup. They lost to Blackburn that night but got their revenge in Round Three of the FA Cup at St James Park, coming from behind to win two-one. The club, as well as the wider football world, had mourned the death of their former captain Gary Speed when the Wales manager took his own life back in November. He appeared in two FA Cup Finals for the Geordies in the late 90’s. Form in the competition in recent years was not too good for the side though, suffering humiliation losing at League Two Stevenage Live on ESPN last season and last made the semis in 2005. Would there be a similar story here today? The Albion would have to lift their game if that were to happen, narrowly getting past League Two Wrexham in a penalty shoot-out in the Replay ten days ago. This followed a disappointing draw at The Amex at the beginning of January. This Saturday tea-time kick-off under the lights would prove to be another memorable one in the early stages at our new home.

NEW Brighton NEW Newcastle NEW Formation

The Teams: Four changes were made from the FA Cup Third Round Replay at Wrexham which set up tonight’s tie at The Amex. In defence captain Gordon Greer and Adam El-Abd came in, as Grant Hall and Romain Vincelot dropped down to the bench. Seventeen-year-old Jake Forster-Caskey started, having impressed and scored against both Southampton and Wrexham this month. Ashley Barnes got the equaliser in the Replay and started here in place of Will Hoskins. The creative threat would come from Will Buckley, who was in form having scored two in the win at Peterborough last time out. Craig Mackail-Smith had an excellent FA Cup record and was looking to notch his first one in the competition for his new side. Liam Bridcutt and Matt Sparrow would provide the wall in front of the defence which included Lewis Dunk, who had been linked with today’s opponents in the past. For Newcastle, Demba Ba was missing on African Cup of Nations duty. Danny Guthrie played for the 150th time in his career. Shola Ameobi and future Brighton loan signing Leon Best were the striking options. Lee Probert was the referee.

NEW Stubbs NEW Harper NEW Barnes NEW Studio

Presentation Team: Hosting proceedings was Ray Stubbs, as he had done for the three previous Live Albion matches on ESPN. His ESPN career began when he launched their Premier League coverage in 2009 with Arsenal’s six-one victory at Everton on the opening day. He joined after a long career with BBC Sport which included hosting their coverage of the Saturday afternoon results service Score on the Red Button, and Final Score on the main channels for the full-times. The latter had been a long-standing part of Grandstand for decades before it turned into a programme in its own right. When it expanded to include news of all the goals as they went in from the first whistle to the last back in 2004, it was Stubbs who was selected for that leaving his Football Focus gig after five years. His pundits were Steve Harper and John Barnes. Harper had experienced both Brighton and Newcastle dressing rooms this season so was in the unique position of knowing both squads very well. He played five times for Brighton in the busy October/November period, signed on the day of the televised West Ham match going straight into the starting XI in place of Casper Ankergren. He had been at Newcastle for over a decade and played in the 1999 FA Cup Final defeat to Manchester United on their way to the historic Treble. For most of his North-East career, Harper was the reserve goalie behind the likes of Shaka Hislop and Shay Given before finally claiming the number one jersey a couple of seasons ago. That didn’t last long and he soon found himself out of favour again.

NEW Kick Off NEW CommsNEW Champion NEW Waddle

With Stubbs and Harper today was John Barnes. He was in the extremely rare position of having done every role of a televised football broadcast during his career; presenter, pundit, co-commentator and reporter. He began as a regular pundit on ITV for their tournament coverage and top-flight highlights show The Premiership before joining Channel 5 as their host of UEFA Cup matches. After a few seasons in the main chair he started to appear more in his more familiar pundit role as well as reporting on the touchline and from their broadcast truck as a tactician specialist on occasions. When Channel 5 held Live Serie A rights on a Sunday afternoon for the 2007/08 season he was their regular co-commentator alongside Tony Jones, thus completing the broadcast set. The nearest I can think of to that before was Bob Wilson, who hosted Football Focus and Live matches for both BBC and ITV, was a pundit on the Beeb, reported at the 1982 World Cup and did the odd commentary for radio way back when. Another one might be Jimmy Hill had hosted and done punditry on Match of the Day, and summarised on Live matches at tournaments and Cup Finals back when the role was not quite as conversational as in the modern game. Whether he was touchline reporter on any Live games seems unlikely. In the commentary box were ESPN’s regular Premier League pairing of Jon Champion and Chris Waddle. The former covered our win at FC United of Manchester last season whilst the latter was behind the mic for the recent Wrexham replay. He spent five seasons making his name as an attacking midfielder from 1980 before securing big moves to Tottenham, Marseille and Sheffield Wednesday. Reporting pitchside was Dave Beckett. He has long been the voice of the Football League round-ups, working for many seasons on ITV’s Football League Extra before doing the same role on the BBC’s Football League Show when the rights transferred in 2009. He continued to freelance across various highlights and magazine programmes, voicing Champions League Weekly, Premier League Review and reporting for ESPN and Channel 5 across various competitions. He’s also a huge Brighton fan and more recently has become the face of the official Club channels, hosting the end of season reviews including the excellent Withdean Years DVD.

NEW Stubbs beach NEW Gullys Girls

The Coverage: ESPN’s presentation team of host Ray Stubbs and pundits Steve Harper and John Barnes presented coverage from pitchside in the corner of The Amex where North Stand met East. They brought their large branded desk to perch around as well as some ESPN banners. Pitchside presenting was all the rage for the satellite broadcaster of the FA Cup in recent times, with their mobile caravan studio from last season providing a quick and flexible solution to a professional broadcast whilst immersing themselves in the match atmosphere. Having just the desk today meant it was easy to slide away for the match and slide back in to the corner for the pre and post game broadcast. The theme tune remained as their specially composed track whilst the title sequence was very similar to last season, showing people going about their pre-match routine before culminating at Wembley Stadium. This match kicked off late on Saturday evening, their regular Live Premier League slot. Coverage began forty-five minutes before the 5.15pm start, as the 3pm matches started to edge towards full-time. The programme opened with Stubbs appearing on Brighton beach, the first part of the show focussed on the match in hand. We received the team news from commentator Jon Champion in-vision, who dissected them with his co-commentator Chris Waddle.

NEW Liv Highlights NEW Perry

The biggest Cup game of the weekend had already taken place that lunchtime Live on ITV; Liverpool against Manchester United. Extended highlights were shown during the build-up, with commentary from Clive Tyldesley. Brighton boss Gus Poyet took our reporter Dave Beckett for a guided tour around the stadium, with this being ESPN’s first visit here. He spoke about the proposed expansion from 22,500 up to 30,000 by filling in the corners next year and eventually adding an upper tier to the East Stand. We saw in the manager’s office, the dressing room and an insight into what the players see on matchday. The proposed new training ground in two years time was mentioned, with blueprints drawn up. In five years time, with all the infrastructure in place, Poyet said “we should be challenging [to be in] the Premiership.” On the back of Beckett’s excellent report, he spoke to chief executive Martin Perry Live in the tunnel. He told of how immensely proud he was of the job they’d done since joining in 1997 and, after a brief technical issue interrupting the pictures, how chairman Tony Bloom was still over in Australia for his winter hibernation so would be missing today’s big match.

NEW Tour NEW Dressing Room

The pundits picked out Craig Mackail-Smith of Brighton and Yohan Cabaye of Newcastle as being the key men. Mackail-Smith has a fantastic FA Cup record for all his clubs, scoring twelve goals in seventeen appearances. After a break midfielder Gary Dicker went into full on banter-mode appearing in a Soccer AM Teammates-style VT where he got to have a laugh at the players expense. Gordon Greer was the “angry Scotsman”, Adam El-Abd “would tackle his own mother” and Ashley Barnes “doesn’t really come out much, he’s quite pasty. Could do with a sunbed.” It’s great to see these sort of things on television, as a club Brighton have had extremely small amounts of exposure so for there to be an interest now shows the team is doing something right. On the back of that Dave Beckett asked Poyet about the inclusion of youngster Jake Forster-Caskey in the side; “Because the way he is, he’s a confident boy. For him, it means the same playing with the kids under-18 in the FA Youth Cup or playing in training in the development group or coming into a big game against Southampton and scoring the first goal. So he’s so confident in what he does that I’m not afraid to play him.” After a bit more chat from the pundits the scene was set and we were raring to go. The teams line ups were re-confirmed by the commentary team shown in-vision, before that final short advert break. ESPN had a new replay transition for this season which still centred around their logo. This year it flashed in from the centre and accelerated towards us to cover the whole screen as the replay started playing. I preferred the previous one.

NEW Dicker NEW Commentary Team

The half-time analysis focussed on the two missed chances from Leon Best, with little else to show by way of goalmouth action. The pundits believed Alan Pardew would be the happier manager of the two, enjoying more possessions and better chances, as the rain began to fall on the pitchside presentation. Upon conclusion of the match reporter Dave Beckett spoke with Man of the Match, as voted for by ESPN viewers, Will Buckley followed by goalkeeper Peter Brezovan, who made a couple of crucial saves to keep the clean sheet. After the break, around twenty minutes or so was afforded to wrap things up. Steve Harper praised the Albion as being solid in midfield and strong in possession without cutting teams open, very much what he witnessed during his shot loan spell. Beckett caught up with winning manager Poyet who praised Buckley’s work ethic; “When everybody goes a little bit tired he keeps sprinting and going past people and he’s been outsanding in terms of scoring at the right times for us.” The pundits reviewed the goal, saying defender Mike Williamson was just unlucky that Buckley’s shot hit him to deflect over Tim Krul in-goal. They looked in detail at the kick out from Cabaye on El-Abd. It was later said by Pardew that he was furious with Ray Stubbs for being “ferocious” in the discussion about the incident and blamed him for getting him restrospectively banned, whereas both pundits seemed to suggest it was just a flick rather than a stamp and should not have been a red card. Stubbs certainly argued the case for a red, more by playing devil’s advocate than anything else. After a little more chat it was time to go, closing the show with “Brighton rocks!”.

NEW CMS NEW Knight

Story of the Match:  This was the first meeting between Brighton and Newcastle in twenty years, with the Albion emerging victorious by the solitary goal to nil that day. Ten minutes into today’s match Leon Best nearly opened the scoring from a long ball over the top, his shot just rolling wide. He had another chance two minutes later when his header off a Shola Ameobi assist flew high over the bar. If Best could finish he would’ve been a far better player. Ameobi was winning headers and getting the better of the Brighton defence often. The home side’s first opening came after half an hour when a decent move was concluded with Craig Mackail-Smith driving the ball high and wide from outside the box. That was the pattern of the first half, with very few chances for either side, little goalmouth action, both teams just sussing each other out in midfield. Into the second half and again it was Best who should’ve opened the scoring. A neat turn and lay off from Ameobi found Best in the box in space, his shot saved by Brezovan. From the resulting corner Ameobi himself got a chance when the cross bounced off the back Dunk, his swing well saved by Brezovan once more. Just after the hour mark there was an incident between Adam El-Abd and Yohan Cabaye where the Newcastle player appeared to kick out towards El-Abd’s face following a tumble. The referee did not spot it and had no help from his assistant so it went unpunished at the time, though retrospective action was taken in the days that followed the match. Into the final twenty minutes the game began to come to life. Mackail-Smith carved a chance out for himself; he span past one defender, shifted wide of another before unleashing a left foot shot twenty yards out which needed to be turned away by Tim Krul. Finally, the break through came. “Buckley, easily away from Simpson. Mackail-Smith pulling away, trying to find space in the middle. Buckley past Cabaye, deflection and in! Brighton’s big moment” was how commentator Jon Champion expertly described the moment. Will Buckley brought the ball forward from around thirty yards inside his own half, skipped past Danny Simpson and ran the length of the Newcastle half to reach the penalty area. His left-footed shot, a somewhat tired effort, took a huge looping deflection off of Mike Williamson on its way through giving Krul no chance. Buckley deserved the goal but it would actually go down as a Williamson own-goal as the shot was actually going wide before the deflection. Nonetheless it was Buckley who rightly took all the plaudits and Brighton had a lead to hang onto for the final fifteen minutes. The Albion defended deep into their own half as nothing was getting past them today. They even survived a clear handball appeal when Barnes was back defending, shielding his face would’ve been the excuse used. In a match of very few chances, Brighton marched through to Round Four at the expense of a top Division team for the first time since 1986. The team knocked out then? Of course, it was Newcastle.

NEW MOTM NEW Poyet

BRIGHTON 1 NEWCASTLE 0
Williamson (Own-Goal)

NEW Replay

EXTRA; Tonight’s late kick off was also the first on ITV’s Saturday night highlights programme. The channel held the terrestrial FA Cup rights, entitling them to up to fifteen Live matches as well as regular round-up shows. Whilst Adrian Chiles was the main Live host, Matt Smith chaired the highlights programmes. The first fifteen minutes or so of the show was given over to probably the biggest upset of the Round that Saturday; our defeat of Newcastle.

ITV Titles ITV Teams

Commentating on proceedings were Jon Champion and Chris Waddle, as per ESPN. The two channels pooled resources to minimise expense. Champion had been heard on ITV since 2001, covering League Cup Finals and Play Off matches for the highlights as well as several World Cups and European Championships for both ITV and BBC. Dave Beckett’s interviews with the two managers post-match were also shown on ITV, Beckett being a regular voice to the goal round-ups. In the studio with Matt Smith were regular pundit Gordon Strachan and Neil Warnock, who had recently left Queens Park Rangers in the Premier League having got them promotion the previous season. They both agreed Newcastle were unlucky, should’ve had a penalty but it was pleasing that Brighton had enjoyed a slice of fortune which their attractive passing style deserved.

ITV Smith ITV Pundits

 

PREVIOUS; #37 WREXHAM 1-1 BRIGHTON 18/01/2012

NEXT; #39 LIVERPOOL 6-1 BRIGHTON 19/02/2012

About Mark O'MEARA
I am Mark O'MEARA.

3 Responses to #38: Brighton 1-0 Newcastle 28/01/2012

  1. Pingback: #37: Wrexham 1-1 Brighton 18/01/2012 | Mark O'MEARA

  2. Pingback: #39: Liverpool 6-1 Brighton 19/02/2012 | Mark O'MEARA

  3. Pingback: Small Screen Seagulls; 2011/12 Season part 2 | Mark O'MEARA

Have your say

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: